Affordable Alternatives to the Tudor Black Bay 58
The Tudor Black Bay 58 is a dive watch in the $2,500–$5,000 band: Automatic Manufacture Calibre MT5402, 39mm case, 200m (20 ATM) water resistance, Domed Sapphire crystal. The 6 watches below are the closest dive watch answers in this catalogue that Amazon stocks under $1,000, ranked by how near their published specification sits to the Black Bay 58's: movement type first, then water resistance, then case size. None of them is a Tudor, and this page makes no claim that any of them looks like one. What it shows is what a buyer gets when the brief is the category and the specification rather than the name.
The reference · Tudor
Black Bay 58Ref. M79030N-0001
Automatic Manufacture Calibre MT5402, 39mm case, 200m (20 ATM) water resistance, Domed Sapphire crystal
How this list is built
Candidates are every dive watch in the catalogue with a verified Amazon price band under $1,000. Each is scored against the Tudor Black Bay 58 on the maker's published figures only: the same movement family (mechanical or quartz) scores highest, then water resistance at or above the Black Bay 58's rating, then a case within two millimetres, then a matching crystal material. We do not test watches, and we do not rate resemblance. Prices are shown as bands, never exact figures, because they change daily.
Bulova
Devil Diver Oceanographer 96B350
Automatic Miyota 8215, 41mm case, 200m (20 ATM) water resistance, Sapphire Crystal crystal
Compare with the Black Bay 58
Tissot
Seastar 1000 Automatic
Automatic Powermatic 80 (Caliber 80.111), 40mm case, 300m (30 ATM) water resistance, Sapphire Crystal crystal
Compare with the Black Bay 58
Orient
Mako 40 Green
Automatic Caliber F6722, 40mm case, 200m (20 ATM) water resistance, Sapphire Crystal crystal
Compare with the Black Bay 58
Orient
Kamasu Automatic Diver
Automatic Caliber F6922, 41.8mm case, 200m (20 ATM) water resistance, Sapphire Crystal crystal
Compare with the Black Bay 58
Invicta
Pro Diver Automatic
Automatic Seiko NH35, 40mm case, 200m (20 ATM) water resistance, Mineral Glass crystal
Compare with the Black Bay 58
Invicta
Pro Diver Automatic 23681
Automatic NH35A, 40mm case, 200m water resistance, Mineral Glass crystal
Compare with the Black Bay 58Try Amazon Prime Free for 30 Days
Free shipping on every watch above
Frequently Asked
Common Questions
On published specification, the Bulova Devil Diver Oceanographer 96B350 is the nearest dive watch in this catalogue under $1,000: Automatic Miyota 8215, 41mm case, 200m (20 ATM) water resistance, Sapphire Crystal crystal. It sits in the $500–$1,000 band against the Black Bay 58's $2,500–$5,000. The Tissot Seastar 1000 Automatic is the next closest.
This page does not rate looks. It lists dive watchs that match the Black Bay 58 on movement type, water resistance and case size at Amazon prices, which is the honest version of the question. Whether a design resembles the Black Bay 58 is for your eyes; the specification lines on each card are the maker's own.
The Bulova Devil Diver Oceanographer 96B350 (Automatic Miyota 8215), the Tissot Seastar 1000 Automatic (Automatic Powermatic 80 (Caliber 80.111)), the Orient Mako 40 Green (Automatic Caliber F6722), the Orient Kamasu Automatic Diver (Automatic Caliber F6922), the Invicta Pro Diver Automatic (Automatic Seiko NH35), the Invicta Pro Diver Automatic 23681 (Automatic NH35A). They are the mechanical options on this list; the rest run on quartz or solar movements, which are more accurate and need less servicing.
Amazon prices change daily and Associates rules do not allow us to publish a fixed figure. The band tells you where a watch sits today; the button opens the live listing.
More alternatives
Affiliate Disclosure
The Horologist is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never influences our editorial recommendations — every timepiece is selected on merit alone.